Monte Carlo analysis is a statistical way to analyze a circuit. This simulation allows us to test the process variation and mismatching between devices in a single chip or wafer.
What is the difference with the CORNER ANALYSIS?
The Corner analysis simulates your design with the minimum and maximum value of each parameter. But it does not reproduce the mismatching between devices! The corner analysis makes the problem much harder than it really is. It simulates extreme cases, that in real fabrication process will never occur, because of the correlation between parameters are not taken in account.
A basic corner analysis can be around 65 simulations, taking the maximum and minimum of the process variables:
- CMOS thickness: wp, ws, wo, wz.
- Resistor value: wp, ws.
- Capacitor value: wp, ws.
- Temperatures: (typ.)-20 to 85ºC
- Voltage supply: depend on your supply source, etc.
Typical number of simulations: tm+ 4CMOS*2RES*2CAP*2TEMP*2Vsupply = 65
- ws = worse speed
- wp = worse power
- wo = worse one
- wz = worse zero
For example, if the CMOS gate oxide thickness is big for NMOS, it will be also big for the NMOS. It is not realistic to simulate the case when the thickness of the NMOS is minimum and the PMOS is maximum.
Corner analysis guarantees that the circuit will work, of course, under all possible consideration, but it overdesigns your circuit.
Monte Carlo Simulation in Circuit Design
Monte Carlo analysis is based on statistical distributions. It simulates mismatching and process variation in a realistic way. On each simulation run, it calculates every parameter randomly according to a statistical distribution model. With this analysis, you will see in which region your circuit will work most of the time.
The drawback of Monte Carlo is the large amount of simulations required to have acceptable results. It should be at least 250 to have a significant sample, but the minimum amount of simulations is not trivial (it follows the statistical model), but as a thumb rule, the more simulation the more significant the test is.
The amount of simulations to run with Monte Carlo, is much higher comparison than the Corner analysis.
Coming back to the previous example with the gate oxide thickness:
In the corner analysis it is simulated the worst case of the minimum and maximum values of the thickness parameter resulting in a variation of the threshold voltage:
But in real fabrication cases, if the NMOS is thin, the PMOS transistor will have also similar thickness. This area is shown in the yellow region.
Another type of corner analysis is known as “statistical corner models”, here thousands of real produced wafers are measured. Now the statistical corner analysis considers correlations of map parameters. This analysis improves the Monte Carlo pure statistical method with the feedback of the real wafer measurements.
Actualization: Example of Monte Carlo simulation in Cadence
In this example, a clock is going to be simulated. This clock has a configurable frequency output from 0.84MHz to 1.88MHz depending on a digital input of 4 bits (16 steps).
First, we make sure that the simulation is working fine in nominal conditions and try to shorten the simulation time as much as possible. If you want to run hundreds or even thousands of simulations, you have to optimize your computational resources.
- Reducing the amount of time (in the ~microseconds range normally) to be simulated for each run.
- Adjusting carefully the resolution steps.
- Selecting only the minimal amount of nets to be saved. But they have to be the minimum necessary to interpret the results and detect where the problem may come from.
In the following picture, the nominal results for the clock are shown. The frequency f_0 and f_15 are the values to be tested on the simulation. The nominal values are 836kHz and1.89MHz. Let’s see later how much do they change with the process variations…
Before Monte Carlo, normally a corner simulation is performed, in order to have a preview of the worse case and see the bounded of the Monte Carlo simulation. For this example, the Process Corners simulations looked like:
To proceed with the Monte Carlo:
First, select “Monte Carlo Sampling” (as the picture below shows) and choose the number of simulations on the configuration window:
Later go to the Corners set-up, as shown in the picture below, and choose the parameters you want to vary, Usually, the temperature and other parameters. In my case, I want variations on the temperature (-20-to+85°C) and in VDD (the power supply from 1.1V to 1.3V). Then depending on the technology used, you will have another Monte Carlo model files.
Deactivate the nominal simulation because we already run and saved it. Then, run the Monte Carlo pressing the green play button.
The results “Yield” window will appears similar to the picture below. In this window, the average, standard deviation, and other statistical parameters are shown.
In Monte Carlo, a histogram plot is used to see graphically the results. For this, click on the historiogram icon and then select “histogram” as shown in the screen shot below.
A new window will prompt, and there you can play with the parameters or selecting which data you want to plot. If you want to combine all the cases you plotted (in my case 4 cases because of 2 temperatures and 2 VDD). You can press “Combine” to plot all together as shown in the next picture:
Then you can export the graph choosing a white background. This is very useful and will give you way better appearance when you insert it in your documentation or reports:
Example of Monte Carlo simulation in Cadence with ADE-XL
In this other example, a cascade circuit is going to be used to make the Monte Carlo simulation.
First, add the Dc- simulation to save the operation point of the circuit.
To have a good performance, you can put many jobs in parallel, depending on how many cores does your machine has. For this example I was using a 8 core machine, so I set 8 simulations in parallel.
Go to Options>> Job setup.
Make a DC-simulation a plot the currents.
Add this values from the calculator into the output window in the ADE XL.
Copy this expression and paste them on the ADE XL.
You can add them by Outputs>>Setup
You should get something like. Delete every corner and leave one, that we are going to use as a reference.
We want to make the Monte Carlo Simulation for the nmos transistor, we chose the model cmosmc (Monte Carlo). If we wanted the Monte Carlo for the resistor you should chose “resmc”.
Select it on the Data View.
Go to options for the Monte Carlo Simulation
Set the configuration parameters. Set to process if you want to check the changes on the process in the electrical parameters. If you want to test the changes by matching on the transistors, select then Mismatch. And the number of points, start with something low, for testing, then you can increase it to a larger amount of simulations.
After the simulation, you can right-click and select “historiogram” to plot the results.
For a larger number of simulations: